Southernmost House

We arrived early and requested an early check in and they stated they could accommodate us, however we checked in at 3 PM the normal check in time. And only after we went back into the hotel at 3 did we get our room key. I rated them as such because they didn't even take our luggage to our room. For $370 per night that would have been nice. Also, we had scheduled a trip and had to leave the hotel before the breakfast was served at 8 AM. I asked the gentlemen at the front desk if he could ready a few bites to eat for us before we left for our trip, he wouldn't do it. Again, for that much money you would think the hotel would try and accommodate a simple request. On a positive note, the pool is beautiful, and that little restaurant serves the best conch fritters and coconut shrimp in Key West. Oh and Mack the bartender. killer delicious gold margaritas, best ever.

My husband and I had a wonderful time. Staff was very friendly and helpful. Breakfast was great!

Wonderful

Great location at the foot of Duval Street exceptionally friendly and helpful staff some areas of the property are looking a little tired and maybe could do with some tlc. The on-site cafe and bar are fab and reasonably priced. There was building work ongoing during the stay between the two properties which may cause some noise and was not mentioned at time of booking.

First time to Key West in 25 years. The hotel had a lot of charm and character. On the quiet end of Duval Street. The staff was friendly & helpful. The only complaint, was the roosters started crowing at around 6am or so and didn’t stop. So not too much sleeping in. Overall, it’s a great hotel & I would stay again the next time in Key West.